Deep DiveSafety Leadership

55 Years In, We’re Still Figuring Out Safety

55 Years In, We’re Still Figuring Out Safety

Someone entering the construction safety profession today might assume the industry has always operated the way it does now. We have safety degrees, professional certifications, training programs, conferences, consultants, and entire departments dedicated to workplace safety.

But the modern federally regulated safety system we work under today is only about 55 years old. We’ve made considerable progress during those years, yet we’re still learning how to prevent injuries and improve workplace safety. New approaches continue to emerge as our understanding of what makes a successful safety program changes.

Safety Didn’t Begin With OSHA

Workplace safety existed long before the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. Companies had safety rules, insurance companies were involved in accident prevention, and professional organizations worked to improve workplace conditions. The American Society of Safety Professionals traces its beginnings to 1911.

The Occupational Safety and Health Act, signed into law on December 29, 1970, changed the direction of workplace safety in the United States. OSHA officially began operating on April 28, 1971.

The new federal regulatory system established enforceable workplace safety requirements across much of the American workforce. Employers faced new obligations, while inspectors, consultants, and safety personnel worked to understand what compliance required.

The profession existed before OSHA, but the modern regulatory environment created new responsibilities and accelerated the development of the safety industry we recognize today.

The Early Years Were About Figuring Things Out

Consider what construction companies were facing during the 1970s. New federal requirements needed to be understood and implemented. Companies had to determine how those requirements applied to their operations and what equipment was necessary. They also had to figure out how to train employees to follow the rules.

Safety professionals were learning alongside the companies they supported. During the 1980s, safety programs continued developing as training expanded and enforcement practices evolved. More companies established dedicated safety positions, developing programs around their operations and available resources.

The profession was also beginning to look more closely at how safety should be managed. In 1989, OSHA published voluntary Safety and Health Program Management Guidelines emphasizing management commitment, employee involvement, hazard analysis, and prevention. These guidelines were not mandatory regulations. They reflected a growing understanding that effective safety management required more than simply complying with regulations.

By the 1990s, safety had become more established, but many professionals entering construction safety were still developing their knowledge through practical experience.

When I entered the safety profession in the mid-1990s, we didn’t have the same educational opportunities and professional resources available to people entering the field today. Safety degree programs existed, but they weren’t something I commonly encountered in construction. Much of what we learned came from working in the field, attending training, studying regulations, and learning from others who had experience. We were still figuring out how to make safety programs work.

Younger safety professionals should understand that the resources available to them today developed over time. Earlier generations helped establish the foundations we now build upon.

History of safety

Every New Approach Promised to Improve Safety

Regulatory compliance became a major foundation. Companies focused on meeting OSHA standards through inspections and training while working to correct violations. Those responsibilities remain essential, but compliance alone doesn’t address every risk associated with construction operations.

Behavior-based safety brought additional attention to what employees do while performing their work. Observations and feedback became important parts of many programs, along with efforts to reinforce safer practices. This approach contributed useful insights into employee behavior, but it also raised concerns about placing too much responsibility on workers without examining the conditions influencing their decisions.

Accountability became another major discussion. Companies examined how managers and supervisors should be held responsible for workplace safety, along with the employees performing the work. Accountability can help establish clear expectations, but it must be applied fairly. Employees also need the training and equipment necessary to meet those expectations, along with the authority to act when something is wrong.

Safety culture expanded the conversation beyond individual behavior. Companies began examining how leadership decisions influence workplace conditions and whether organizational expectations were consistent with what actually happened in the field. Communication and management practices became a larger part of the discussion.

More recently, psychological safety has received greater attention. This concept examines whether employees feel comfortable speaking up about concerns or admitting mistakes without fear of embarrassment or inappropriate retaliation. Although psychological safety isn’t a complete workplace safety management system, it can help organizations identify problems that employees might otherwise hesitate to report.

These approaches didn’t emerge in a perfectly defined sequence, and one hasn’t necessarily replaced another. Many developed alongside each other, with different organizations adopting them at different times. Their continued development reflects how the profession has expanded its understanding of workplace safety rather than simply abandoning earlier ideas.

In 2016, OSHA published updated Recommended Practices for Safety and Health Programs, including guidance specifically for construction. The recommendations addressed management leadership and worker participation, with an emphasis on identifying and controlling workplace hazards. They also encouraged organizations to continually evaluate and improve their safety programs. OSHA’s evolving guidance reflects how our understanding of effective safety management has developed.

Why Do We Keep Searching for the Answer?

The safety profession has a tendency to become enthusiastic about new approaches. A new philosophy appears, books are written about it, and conferences begin featuring presentations on the subject. Companies then start adopting the concepts, sometimes before fully understanding how they apply to their operations.

Some organizations see valuable improvements. Others discover that implementing a particular philosophy doesn’t produce the results they expected. The problem may be expecting one approach to solve every workplace safety challenge.

Regulatory compliance remains necessary, and understanding employee behavior can help improve workplace practices. Accountability establishes expectations while organizational culture influences how decisions are made. Psychological safety can encourage employees to communicate concerns that might otherwise go unreported.

These approaches can work together, but none eliminates the need to recognize hazards and establish effective controls. A worker exposed to a fall hazard needs appropriate protection, regardless of how strong the company’s safety culture might be. Providing effective fall protection equipment also doesn’t guarantee employees understand how to use it properly.

Construction operations are complex, and conditions affecting workplace safety are rarely identical from one project to another. Different problems require different solutions. We may accomplish more by learning how to apply the effective parts of these approaches together instead of searching for one philosophy that answers everything.

What Younger Safety Professionals Should Understand

Someone entering the safety profession today has access to educational opportunities and professional resources that earlier generations couldn’t always obtain as easily. Understanding how those resources developed can help younger professionals appreciate the work that brought the industry to where it is today.

Many practices we use came from professionals trying to solve problems with the information available to them. Some ideas worked while others needed improvement. The approaches we’re using today will face the same scrutiny as the profession continues to develop.

Education provides a foundation, but learning continues throughout a career. Experience brings perspective, although it shouldn’t become a reason to dismiss new research or different approaches. Younger professionals can benefit from the knowledge of those who came before them, and experienced professionals should be willing to learn from the next generation.

Construction Owners Have a Role in This Evolution

Business owners shouldn’t expect their safety director to arrive with a program that solves every safety problem. They should expect someone who understands the work and recognizes hazards, while helping the organization identify practices that need improvement.

Successful safety programs also depend on operational leadership. A superintendent who plans work effectively and provides the right equipment contributes directly to workplace safety. Responding to employee concerns is another part of that responsibility.

The safety department can provide expertise and guidance, but it cannot independently control every decision made in the field. Safety needs to become more closely integrated with how companies operate, with safety professionals and operational leaders working together to improve how the work gets done.

We’re Still Learning, and That’s a Good Thing

Fifty-five years isn’t a long time when considering the development of a modern regulatory system and the professional practices that have grown around it. We’ve learned a considerable amount since 1971, but there’s more to learn.

Future safety professionals will introduce ideas that challenge some of what we believe today. Research and technology will influence how companies manage workplace risks, just as operational experience has shaped our thinking over the years. We should welcome that process while remaining willing to question whether new ideas actually improve conditions.

When I wrote Stop Being the Safety Cop, I never intended it to be the final answer to running a successful safety program. I wanted to share what I’ve learned throughout my career and provide guidance that might help other safety professionals, particularly those early in their careers, better understand their role and learn how to influence change.

I continue learning myself, and I recognize that other professionals have experiences and perspectives worth considering. My book reflects what I’ve learned throughout my career, but I know there is more to understand.

The same applies to our profession. We should be willing to question what we believe and recognize when something isn’t working. New approaches deserve consideration when they offer a better way to protect people.

We’re still figuring out safety. And that’s exactly why we need to keep learning.

The downtown Denver skyline at sunset, the sun dropping behind the Front Range.

Next Step

Join the Community

Get notified when Troy's books launch, plus receive new Insights and occasional updates.